Penne 4 Your Thoughts

Penne Cole's thoughts on food, travel and more

Cheap eats: Bagels at Melbourne’s 5 and Dime

Bagels galore at 5 and Dime

Bagels galore at 5 and Dime

I don’t think I’ve had a decent bagel since I left New York City nine years ago. I miss living in the Big Apple, if only because it meant that I could pop over to the nearest deli and get a delicious bagel. Seemed like every deli in New York had good bagels, but outside America, a decent bagel is as rare as hen’s teeth.

So I was pleasantly surprised to find that Melbourne’s 5 and Dime had not just a decent bagel, but actually a pretty good one.

First, a bit of the back story. New Jersey Chef Zev Forman came to Melbourne, decided that the bagels just weren’t up to scratch, and decided to make his own. Cue the theme music and the Rocky-style training sequence: Zev goes to New York and San Francisco to train with the best bagel makers in the business, then comes back to Melbourne where he starts selling his creations at farmers’ markets. Two years later, he’s done well enough to open his own CBD café, complete with glass-walled kitchen where his minions churn out rack after rack of delicious bagels.

Assorted pastries

Assorted pastries

5 and Dime’s bagels come in nine flavours – plain, onion, rye, poppy, everything, cinnamon & raisin, sesame, salt and dill. Bagels are $2 each or $11 for half a dozen. Of course, you can’t have a café that just sells plain bagels, so patrons get their choice of cream cheese (plain or flavoured), butter, or PB&J. And no bagel place is complete if it doesn’t have the classic lox and cream cheese, so of course, that’s on the menu too. But if you’re not after bagels, they’ve also got some other pastries on offer.

Lox and cream cheese bagel

Lox and cream cheese bagel

My lox and cream cheese bagel came with a healthy schmear of cream cheese (although not as full-on as those in New York, where the cream cheese is easily an inch thick) and a decent amount of house-cured lox. As the star of the show, the bagel is the perfect combination of chewiness and fluffiness. I would have loved to do the overnight test – leave it out overnight and see whether it’s rock hard in the morning – but I was leaving that day. Too bad. I’ll be sure to next time, although with bagels this good, having any leftovers would be a challenge.

Related post: awesome breakfast at Melbourne’s Grain Store.

Practical Information

5 and Dime

Katherine Place

Melbourne, Vic 3000

03 9621 2128

Open Monday to Friday, 7am to 3pm


5 comments on “Cheap eats: Bagels at Melbourne’s 5 and Dime

  1. James
    July 7, 2015

    lox and cream cheese bagel is a superb choice. nuff said. 🙂

  2. James
    July 12, 2015

    Reblogged this on POCbooksjava and commented:
    You will love her blog! But careful, it makes you hungry – Kind regards

    • Penne Cole
      September 6, 2015

      Thanks, James! Sorry I’ve been off the radar recently. Life has been busy! How are you doing?

      • James
        September 6, 2015

        Hi Penne, this is just a little something I did on your website. I just finished it yesterday. By the way, the music in the background is Arianna Morgan’s “Songbird”
        It is always good to hear from you.

  3. Pingback: Opposites: Black and white bagel | Penne 4 Your Thoughts

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on June 27, 2015 by in Australia, Cheap Eats, Food, Travel and tagged , , .
Giles Meets World

Travel Tips To Make Travel Happen

What Am I Doing With My Life?

The Musings of an English Millennial.

Eye For A Pic

Eye Catching Photography

The ancient eavesdropper

Nature's nuances in a nutshell

Please Pass the Recipe

from one generation to the next

Autumn beats

The beats to my life

Life Confusions

"I Will Find Words, Smith them Down. For Love Is Infinite And So Are They."


exploring the world

%d bloggers like this: